Why is Bioremediation preferred over Traditional Remediation techniques ?

Why is Bioremediation preferred over Traditional Remediation techniques ?

Introduction

What is Bioremediation?

Bioremediation leverages plants and microorganisms to reduce environmental pollutants, working through two primary mechanisms: mobilization and immobilization (refer to our blog on Bioremediation and its types). 

  • Mobilization technique employs the use of desorbing agents, surfactants, or chelating agents, to remove pollutants [4]
  • Immobilization technique transforms toxic substances into more stable forms, ensuring they no longer pose a threat to the environment [4]

Classification of Bioremediation 

Bioremediation can be categorized into two types based on the location of treatment:  

  1. Ex Situ Bioremediation [4]: 
  • Involves extracting contaminated materials for treatment at another location. 
  • Requires heavy machinery and is often cost-intensive. 
  1. In Situ Bioremediation [4]: 
  • Treats contaminants directly at the site, causing minimal disturbance to the surrounding environment. 
  • Eliminates the need to transport large volumes of wastewater, making it a more cost-effective solution.  

Comparison: Traditional vs. Bioremediation [7]

 Traditional Techniques Bioremediation 
Approach Uses chemical agents or physical methods [3] [8]. Gives the solutions for the immediate symptoms without addressing the root cause.   Utilizes microorganisms to degrade pollutants. Addresses the root cause while solving the symptoms 
Eco-Friendliness Limited due to chemical residues and disruptions [3]Highly eco-friendly, avoiding harmful residues. 
Impact on Microbiota Reduces soil fertility by harming microbial populations. Enhances microbial activity, improving fertility. 
Residue Persistence Chemicals can accumulate, causing long-term harm [3]Leaves no harmful residues. 
Effectiveness Temporary, addressing symptoms. Sustainable, tackling root causes. 
Suitability for Water Limited, harming aquatic ecosystems. Ideal for marine environments. 
Cost Expensive due to chemicals and equipment. Cost-effective, relying on natural processes. 
Case studies   1. MV Wakashio Oil Spill (Mauritius, 2020) [6]: 
Event: Nearly 1,000 metric tons of fuel spilled into a marine protected area. 
Response: Containment booms and dispersants were deployed. 
Outcome: Ineffective in preventing long-term damage; significant harm to coral reefs and fisheries. 

2. X-Press Pearl Incident (Sri Lanka, 2021) [6]: 
Event: Hazardous cargo spilled into the sea after a vessel fire. 
Response: Containment techniques like use of chemical dispersants were employed. 
Outcome: Breaches in safety measures led to lasting ecological harm. 
1. TERI’s Microbial Remediation (Gujarat, India) [8]: 
Event: Addressed soil polluted with high Total Petroleum Hydrocarbon (TPH) levels. 
Response: Applied microbial agents to degrade hydrocarbons. 
Outcome: Reduced TPH levels from 14% to 0.5% in four months without harming soil or flora. 

2. Exxon Valdez Oil Spill (Alaska, 1989) [9]: 
Event: Spillage of 11 million gallons of crude oil. 
Response: Natural oil-degrading bacteria and nutrient sprays were used to enhance microbial activity. 
Outcome: Significant oil degradation within a year; ecological recovery with improved wildlife populations. 
This table demonstrates the drawbacks of Traditional Remediation Techniques and Highlights the advantages of Bioremdiation with 2 case studies mentioned.

Conclusion 

Bioremediation is poised to complement and eventually replace traditional methods for addressing ecological crises such as oil spills and industrial pollution. By leveraging the natural capabilities of plants and microorganisms, bioremediation provides an efficient, localized, and sustainable approach to ecosystem restoration. Its eco-friendly nature and cost-effectiveness make it an essential tool for achieving long-term environmental health and sustainability. 

About AgroMorph 

Agromorph was founded to create nature-inspired solutions addressing environmental challenges arising from urbanization. We prioritize environmentally conscious practices while ensuring economic feasibility in our approach. Originally starting as an algal ingredient company, we have evolved to provide low-cost, low-footprint turnkey solutions tailored to our clients’ needs. Our unique offerings center on robust algae and scalable photobioreactor designs, making our solutions versatile for various applications. We are dedicated to harnessing the full potential of algae, believing that tackling climate challenges requires a multifaceted approach and innovative solutions across different fronts. 

References

  1. https://www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2018-01/documents/ospguide99.pdf 
  1. https://lonestarhazmat.com/what-is-environmental-remediation/#:~:text=Polluted%20air%2C%20water%2C%20and%20soil,people%20from%20their%20harmful%20effects
  1. https://response.restoration.noaa.gov/about/media/how-do-oil-spills-out-sea-typically-get-cleaned.html#:~:text=Chemical%20Dispersants%3A%20Break%20It%20Up,easily%20into%20the%20water%20column
  1. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/agronomy/articles/10.3389/fagro.2023.1183691/full 
  2. https://www.teriin.org/technology/oilzapper-and-oilivorous-s
  1. https://maritimeindia.org/legacies-learnings-a-case-study-of-oil-spills-in-the-indian-ocean-region/ 
  1. https://www.hilarispublisher.com/open-access/bioremediation-vs-traditional-remediation-methods-a-comparative-analysis.pdf 
  1. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6784225/#:~:text=Various%20amendments%2C%20including%20the%20augmentation,the%20phytoextraction%20capacity%20in%20plants
  2. https://darrp.noaa.gov/oil-spills/exxon-valdez

Connect With Us

Scroll to Top